David Fedeles, St. Croix Real Estate

Coldwell Banker St. Croix Realty

  • Featured Properties
    • Private Residences
    • Luxury Condos
    • Land
    • Commercial
  • Property Search
    • Residential
      • St. Croix Residential Listings up to $400,000
      • St. Croix Residential Listings $400,000 – $700,000
      • St. Croix Residential Listings $700,000 – $999,999
      • 1 Million & Up
    • Condos
      • Condos up to $300,000
      • Condos $300,000 – $500,000
      • Condos $500,000 and up
    • Land
      • Land up to $100,000
      • Land $100,000 – $200,000
      • Land $200,000 – $500,000
    • Commercial
      • Commercial Fee Simple
      • Commercial Leaseholds
    • Search by Area
    • All Property Search
  • Work With Us
    • St. Croix Buyers
      • St. Croix Buyer Agency
      • St. Croix Property Taxes
      • St. Croix Buyer’s Closing Costs
      • St. Croix Mortgages
      • USVI Tax Incentives
    • St. Croix Sellers
      • Why List With Us
      • Seller’s Closing Costs
    • Homeowner Resources
  • St. Croix
    • St. Croix Map
    • Island Living
    • Moving to St. Croix
  • What’s New
Home » Property Search

2 et al North Star NB, St. Croix, 00840 (MLS# 25-1581)


$2,900,000
2 et al North Star NB
St. Croix, 00840
MLS# 25-1581
2 beds  |  2 baths  |  2100 sqft

 | 

Welcome to North Star!
  1 / 58  
Welcome to North Star! Original Sugar Mill - residence with additions 69 acres - 5 parcels The structures from above Mt Eagle to the water Pool with view of Hamm's Bluff Ruins dating back to the late 1700's View from the bedroom in the Sugar Mill residence One bedroom cottage 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_214 Let's begin the tour.....up the driveway First stop - one bed/1 bath cottage 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_192 Kitchen Dining area on the open floor plan Living area with french doors to bedroom Bedroom with casement windows 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_208 Bedroom with exit to outdoor patio Bathroom 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_211 Back patio Patio with doors to bedroom and living room The Sugar Mill Residence - 2 bed / 2 Bath A beautiful manicured lawn With a stunning backdrop 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_092 The estate dotted with tropical flamboyants Gorgeous arches Living Room Dining Room 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_155 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_163 Bedroom 1 Downstairs Bathroom Laundry Room Over 1,300 feet of shoreline 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_144 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_165 Upstairs bedroom 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_172 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_175 Balcony off the bedroom Upstairs bathroom 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_179 Pool! Stairs to the pool Knoll top - new structure or extra parking Old foundation in front of ruins Ruins 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_119 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_122 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_186 The shoreline Mount Eagle 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_019 2_3_4_4AB_NorthStar_024 Enchantment awaits

Property Description
69 verdant acres nestled on the waterfront descent of St. Croix's highest peak, Mount Eagle with an original Sugar Mill, two residence, pool and countless historic ruins. These five North Star parcels were part of a plantation used for growing sugar cane in the 1800's. The parcels all include waterfront portions across North Shore Road totalling 1,328 feet of shoreline, of which almost half is sandy beach. These beachheads are the shortest swim on the North Shore to ''The Wall'' which makes it a diver's paradise and presents tremendous opportunity for vacation rentals. Panoramic views of Hams Bluff and St. Thomas are your constant companions. Continued...

Details
Maps
Documents
Location/Area
Plot/Unit Number: 2 et al
Island: St. Croix
Quarter: Northside 'B'
General Property Description
Realtor.COM Type: Multi-Family
Number of Bedrooms - Main House: 1
Number of Bedrooms - Accessory building: 1
Taxes: 6745.04
Furnished: Yes
Tax Year: 2025
Lot Acres: 69.28
Water Front: Yes
Waterfront Type: Rocky Beach
Pool: Yes
Zoning: R-1
Stamp Tax: Paid by Buyer
Approx Interior SqFt-Accessory Unit Total: 0
Approx Exterior SqFt-Accessory Unit Total: 0
Approx Total Main House: 1310
Approx Total Property SqFt: 2100
Total Bedrooms: 2
Total Bathrooms: 2
Sub Type: 2 - 4 Multi Units
Year Built: 1967
Contract Information
Concessions: No
List Price: $2,900,000
Current Price: $2,900,000
Begin Date: 2025-08-14
Miscellaneous
PWD#: 1900,5131,267
Amenities
Ruins: 1
View
Hillside: 1
Neighborhood: 1
Ocean: 1
Sea: 1
Appliance
Fans: Yes
Construction
Concrete Block: 1
Masonry: 1
Flooring
Tile: 1
Exterior
Beach: On Property
Landscape: Lush
Road
Dirt: 1
Gravel: 1
Security
Gate: 1
Water Source
Cistern: 1
Terrain
Beach Front: 1
Hillside: 1
Main House
Approx Interior SqFt - Main House: 1310
Approx Exterior SqFt - Main House: 0
LocationArea
Estate: North Star NB
Postal Code: 00840
Geo Lat: 17.767724
Geo Lon: -64.817336
Directions: From the west, at the bottom of the Beast on River Road, turn right onto North Shore Road and take the first right at the gate. From the east, pass The Landings on your left. The property is about a mile down the road on the left. You will see a black gate.
Status Change Info
Status: Active
Property Features
View: Hillside; Neighborhood; Ocean; Sea
Amenities: Ruins
Flooring: Tile
Construction: Concrete Block; Masonry
Water Source: Cistern
Road: Dirt; Gravel
Terrain: Beach Front; Hillside
Security: Gate
Supplements
A descriptive history of North Star as written by the National Archives and Records Service in Washington DC, can be found in the documents section. This sanctuary is gated for privacy, the first stop at the North Star Estate up the .2-mile driveway is a one-bedroom cottage with private patio and parking. The cottage is flanked by a large Flamboyant tree with stunning orange-red blooms, multiple Palm Trees and a Lime Tree at the doorway. Four large windows grace the western facade of the home. Built in the West Indian vernacular, two of the windows are over a foot deep and can be used as window seats for gazing at the lush flora and fauna. This spacious open floor plan cottage has new doors that allow lots of light in. The cottage has some small windows on the patio side that highlight traditional West Indian design. Across the driveway from the cottage is a nook that can be used for cottage parking....a few steps in reveal ruins of buildings dating back to the 1750's. Any explorers dream! Continue ascending the driveway and park in front of the Sugar Mill that has been repurposed into a one bedroom, two-bathroom residence with an upstairs balcony, large patio and a gorgeous lawn with the wallpaper of Hamm's Bluff. A majestic Norfolk pine towers beside the Sugar Mill, standing guard as it sways in the Tradewinds. Turn towards Mount Eagle and you will find a staircase to the pool with a large concrete deck that overlooks the Sugar Mill, Hamm's Bluff and the ocean. You can put your toes in while watching the waves roll in to Davis Bay. Above the pool is a large grassy pad cut into hilltop which is perfect for parking cars whenever you are entertaining large groups. The dense flora and fauna as you ascend Mount Eagle is untouched. A haven for birds, hermit crabs, and deer. Rich, fertile soil that has been at rest for centuries after years of toil as a working plantation is perfect canvas for sustainable farming, gardens or eco-tourism development. The smells of earthy, clean forestry are a naturalists dream. This landscape is perfect for hiking or walking trails. These parcels are rare in that access is a breeze on the well paved meandering shoreline road equidistant between Cane Bay and the Carambola Beach Resort. But the instant you are on the estate, you feel like you are in another world and back in time. The main ruins feature many beautiful arches, Danish yellow brick and construction that has stood the test of time. Step inside the ruins and feel the temperature go down. Thick walls and coral stone that complement the island climate. These ruins are an archaeologists dream come true. Please note that there are ruins throughout the entire property - walls and structures at every turn. This estate in its present condition represent a blank slate ready for a variety of paths to it's next incarnation: Investment property - tremendous opportunity as a vacation rental for all types of travellers. A divers haven due to its proximity to the VI's best dive site; history buff; eco tourists; or just those vacationers wanting to experience something special and to get off the beaten path. Private estate living- a peaceful retreat to call home for the owner with the option of long-term rental income. Luxury Rental Compound or Boutique eco-resort. Preservation Opportunity - ideal for someone passionate about history and conservation. There is a foundation of a former residence on property and a large cistern to the south of the Mill that could serve as the foundation of a new structure. This is a piece of St. Croix history ready to be rediscovered. Schedule your private showing today and experience the enchantment of North Star. The 100 acres to the west of this property is conservation land, another bonus to this remarkable offering.
Listing Documents
View Document PWD 0267
View Document PWD 1900
View Document National Archives History of North Star
View Document SUPPLEMENT NORTH STAR
View Document Directions
View Document HOLD HARMLESS STATEMENT

Listing Office: Calabash Real Estate

Office Phone: 340-718-5285

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.


Search powered by FBS Products
FIND YOUR DREAM PROPERTY
Property Type
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Select one or more locations to search for properties
to
to
Active
Pending
More Search Options

Contact Us

Would you like to learn more about a property you see or are you considering listing your property? We can help!

About David Fedeles

Twice voted Best Real Estate Broker on St. Croix. Coldwell Banker President's Circle three years in a row. Read More…
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

St. Croix and New York

David Fedeles is a licensed real estate broker in both St. Croix USVI and New York. If you are looking for your dream home in America’s Paradise, David is ready to work with you!

Contact David Fedeles today!

Tel: 340-778-7000
Cell: 917-494-2729
davidfedelesstx@gmail.com
Office Location:
Coldwell Banker St. Croix Realty | Gallows Bay Mkt
5030 Anchor Way, Suite 12 | Christiansted, VI 00820

Copyright © 2026 · AgentPress Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in