David Fedeles, St. Croix Real Estate

Coldwell Banker St. Croix Realty

  • Featured Properties
    • Private Residences
    • Luxury Condos
    • Land
    • Commercial
  • Property Search
    • Residential
      • St. Croix Residential Listings up to $400,000
      • St. Croix Residential Listings $400,000 – $700,000
      • St. Croix Residential Listings $700,000 – $999,999
      • 1 Million & Up
    • Condos
      • Condos up to $300,000
      • Condos $300,000 – $500,000
      • Condos $500,000 and up
    • Land
      • Land up to $100,000
      • Land $100,000 – $200,000
      • Land $200,000 – $500,000
    • Commercial
      • Commercial Fee Simple
      • Commercial Leaseholds
    • Search by Area
    • All Property Search
  • Work With Us
    • St. Croix Buyers
      • St. Croix Buyer Agency
      • St. Croix Property Taxes
      • St. Croix Buyer’s Closing Costs
      • St. Croix Mortgages
      • USVI Tax Incentives
    • St. Croix Sellers
      • Why List With Us
      • Seller’s Closing Costs
    • Homeowner Resources
  • St. Croix
    • St. Croix Map
    • Island Living
    • Moving to St. Croix
  • What’s New
Home » Property Search

291 Mary’s Fancy QU, St. Croix, 00820 (MLS# 25-293)


$435,000
291 Mary's Fancy QU
St. Croix, 00820
MLS# 25-293
Status: Closed
4 beds  |  2 baths  |  2376 sqft


291 Mary's Fancy
  1 / 52  
291 Mary's Fancy Welcome home! Entry to main house Side yard Room to expand Plenty of space for parking Freshly painted inside and out Photo 8 Lush tropical foliage Living room/dining Loads of natural light throughout Upstairs kitchen Kitchen 1 Photo 14 Bedroom 1 Bedroom 2 Bedroom 2 Upstairs bath Expansive patio Upstairs patio Sea view Avocado, banana, golden apple Walkway to partment Apartment entrance Photo 25 Downstairs apartment Apartment living area Photo 25 Photo 26 Kitchen/dining Apartment kitchen Butcher block countertops Dine in kitchen Apartment bedroom 1 Bedroom 1 Hallway to bath and bedroom 2 Downstairs apartment bath Apartment bedroom 2 Bedroom 2 Downstairs apartment patio Screened in patio Photo Feb 03 2025, 11 13 19 AM Laundry Laundry and pump house Workshop Workshop interior Driveway More yard space for planting Photo 49 Photo 50 Photo 51 Photo 52

Property Description
Charming Multi-Unit Home in Prime Mid-Island Location! This freshly painted multi-unit property is a fantastic opportunity for investors or those seeking a versatile living space. The home features two separate units—each with 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom—perfect for rental income or multi-generational living. Situated in a lush tropical setting, the expansive yard is adorned with banana, avocado, and sugar apple trees, offering both beauty and sustainability. A bonus workshop provides additional storage or creative space, while ample parking ensures convenience for residents and guests alike. Located in a desirable mid-island location, this property offers easy access to shops, dining, and beaches while maintaining a peaceful residential feel.

Details
Maps
Documents
General Property Description
Realtor.COM Type: Multi-Family
Lot Acres: 0.51
Approx Total Main House: 2376
Approx Total Property SqFt: 2376
SqFt - GLA Main House: 2376
Total Bedrooms: 4
Number of Bedrooms - Main House: 2
Number of Bedrooms - Accessory building: 2
Total Bathrooms: 2
Sub Type: 2 - 4 Multi Units
Taxes: 714.04
Tax Year: 2024
Year Built: 1984
Furnished: No
Water Front: No
Pool: No
Zoning: R-1
Stamp Tax: Negotiable
Contract Information
Sold Price: $435,000
Current Price: $435,000
Begin Date: 2025-02-10
Concessions: Yes
Status Change Info
Status: Closed
Under Contract Date: 2025-02-21
Sold Date: 2025-04-16
Sold Price: $435,000
Intended Use: Primary
Miscellaneous
PWD#: 3154
Appliance
Air Conditioning: 4
Range: 1
Refrigerator: 2
Exterior
Landscape: Lush
Cistern
Approx. Cistern Size: 20000
Main House
Approx Interior SqFt - Main House: 1556
Approx Exterior SqFt - Main House: 820
LocationArea
Estate: Mary's Fancy QU
Postal Code: 00820
Geo Lat: 17.747583
Geo Lon: -64.766757
Directions: Make left after Country Day School. At 'Y' bear left and drive up road behind the Nazarene Church. Go up dirt road. Second house on the right, next drive after wood gate. House is burnt orange and tan in color.
Property Features
View: Neighborhood; Sea
Amenities: Deck; Patio; Work Shop
Flooring: Tile
Construction: Concrete Block; Masonry
Roof: Concrete; Fluid Applied
Water Source: Cistern
Sewer: Septic
Road: Concrete; Gravel
Terrain: High/Flat
Supplements
291 Mary's Fancy Supplement - Concrete roof recoated 2024 - Cistern recoated 2024 - New electrical property wide January 2024 (units separately metered) - Deck improvements (lumbar and guard railings) - New fans installed throughout January 2025 - New light fixtures throughout - Painted inside and out January 2025 - Downstairs repainted 2024 - Shutters refurbished 2024 This solid structure survived hurricanes Hugo and Maria without a scratch!
Listing Documents
View Document As Built
View Document Mapgeo
View Document Topo

Listing Office: Christie's International Real Estate St Croix

Office Phone: 340-715-7749

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.


Search powered by FBS Products
FIND YOUR DREAM PROPERTY
Property Type
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Select one or more locations to search for properties
to
to
Active
Pending
More Search Options

Contact Us

Would you like to learn more about a property you see or are you considering listing your property? We can help!

About David Fedeles

Twice voted Best Real Estate Broker on St. Croix. Coldwell Banker President's Circle three years in a row. Read More…
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

St. Croix and New York

David Fedeles is a licensed real estate broker in both St. Croix USVI and New York. If you are looking for your dream home in America’s Paradise, David is ready to work with you!

Contact David Fedeles today!

Tel: 340-778-7000
Cell: 917-494-2729
davidfedelesstx@gmail.com
Office Location:
Coldwell Banker St. Croix Realty | Gallows Bay Mkt
5030 Anchor Way, Suite 12 | Christiansted, VI 00820

Copyright © 2026 · AgentPress Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in