David Fedeles, St. Croix Real Estate

Coldwell Banker St. Croix Realty

  • Featured Properties
    • Private Residences
    • Luxury Condos
    • Land
    • Commercial
  • Property Search
    • Residential
      • St. Croix Residential Listings up to $400,000
      • St. Croix Residential Listings $400,000 – $700,000
      • St. Croix Residential Listings $700,000 – $999,999
      • 1 Million & Up
    • Condos
      • Condos up to $300,000
      • Condos $300,000 – $500,000
      • Condos $500,000 and up
    • Land
      • Land up to $100,000
      • Land $100,000 – $200,000
      • Land $200,000 – $500,000
    • Commercial
      • Commercial Fee Simple
      • Commercial Leaseholds
    • Search by Area
    • All Property Search
  • Work With Us
    • St. Croix Buyers
      • St. Croix Buyer Agency
      • St. Croix Property Taxes
      • St. Croix Buyer’s Closing Costs
      • St. Croix Mortgages
      • USVI Tax Incentives
    • St. Croix Sellers
      • Why List With Us
      • Seller’s Closing Costs
    • Homeowner Resources
  • St. Croix
    • St. Croix Map
    • Island Living
    • Moving to St. Croix
  • What’s New
Home » Property Search

49,16,17 Green Cay EA, St. Croix, 00820 (MLS# 22-516)


$1,025,000
49,16,17 Green Cay EA
St. Croix, 00820
MLS# 22-516
Status: Closed
5 beds  |  5 baths  |  4096.6 sqft


Green Cay Compound
  1 / 51  
Green Cay Compound Cottage and main house Main house RT/GST House LT Overhead of property Facing east Main house First driveway IMG_5819 House and pool Blooming flowers by pool Two access roads Back road side view Portico looking out Portico main entrance Garden patio Patio IMG_5767 Pool at sunset Gallery off of main house Gallery to interior living room to gallery Living room with views Kitchen Kitchen Turn this room into another bedroom Main bedroom Office / sun room Guest bedroom main house Bathroom 2 main house IMG_5379 Guest house Cottage Sea views from cottage Wrap around gallery Dog run Large living space with stone walls Updated kitchen with views Kitchen to bedroom Cottage bedroom IMG_5795 Kitchen opens to large living room IMG_5818 Apt. 1 living and kitchen Apt. 2 bedroom Apt. 2 Bedroom Apt 2 living and kitchen Apt. 2 bathroom Neighborhood beach Miss Bea Beach Long stretch of beach Walk to this beach

Property Description
Green Cay Hideaway! This amazing property in Green Cay off of Ms Bea road on the east end has FOUR dwellings located on three lots. The primary villa includes a two bedroom, two bathroom main house with a pool PLUS two, one bedroom apartments each with outdoor living space and a full kitchen. A detached one-bedroom cottage has a wrap around gallery, fenced in yard, and sea views abound! The upper-level main portion of the primary villa is extremely spacious including a very large living room that opens to the kitchen, a separate dining room with sea views in every direction, an office/sunroom off of the guest bedroom and a sea facing gallery off of the living room and sunroom/office. Included in the 1.35 acre property is a plot all on its own that you can keep to safeguard the property's

Details
Maps
Documents
General Property Description
Realtor.COM Type: Multi-Family
Lot Acres: 1.35
Approx Total Property SqFt: 4096.6
Total Bedrooms: 5
Number of Bedrooms - Main House: 4
Number of Bedrooms - Accessory building: 1
Total Bathrooms: 5
Sub Type: 2 - 4 Multi Units
Taxes: 2800
Tax Year: 1972
Subdivision: Ms. Bea
Year Built: 1973
Furnished: Appliances Only
Water Front: No
Pool: Yes
Zoning: R-3
Stamp Tax: Negotiable
Status Change Info
Status: Closed
Under Contract Date: 2022-05-15
Sold Date: 2022-09-09
Sold Price: $1,025,000
Intended Use: Other
Miscellaneous
PWD#: 2583
Exterior
Off Street Parking: Off Street
Main House
Approx Interior SqFt - Main House: 2200
Approx Exterior SqFt - Main House: 500
LocationArea
Estate: Green Cay EA
Postal Code: 00820
Geo Lat: 17.758595
Geo Lon: -64.653553
Directions: Heading east, take left onto Ms. Bea road take C lane to top and see parking on right. dead ends at house.
Contract Information
Sold Price: $1,025,000
Current Price: $1,025,000
Begin Date: 2022-03-21
Property Features
View: Buck Island; Neighborhood; Ocean; Sea
Amenities: Ruins
Flooring: Tile
Roof: Pre-Fin Metal
Water Source: Cistern
Sewer: Septic
Road: Paved
Supplements
privacy, sell off separately or build another villa. The building site is PERFECT - sitting on a knoll with sea views including Buck Island. Green Cay is one of the most popular east end neighborhoods much because of the beautiful neighborhood beach that is walking distance from this property. The beach stretches from pull point to the Candle Reef condos all the way to Coakley Bay Plantation (you must walk over a smaller hill that has a path cut out). The property is set back off the main road of Ms. Bea giving it more privacy than most homes in the neighborhood (hence the name Green Cay Hideaway). With dual access and plenty of parking, you can host a lot of guests or vacationers at the same time! This is an ideal property for an investor and has the flexibility for a good return whether long term or short-term renting. The cottage can easily be rented separately or together with the main house if you choose to vacation rent the estate. Ms. Bea Road is no more than 10 minutes to everything you need and want near your Caribbean home  beaches, snorkeling, hiking, sailing, fishing charters, dining, entertainment! Some additions: Generator that runs the cottage and main house. Cottage and Main house with have laundry rooms Cottage is fenced for dogs Neighboring lot includes a historic sugar mill Taxes ID's: Plot 49(Main house): 203100025100/ $1,966.06 Plot 16 (Cottage): 203100021000/$661 Plot 17 (vacant lot): 203100020900/$173.11
Listing Documents
View Document Model Sketch survey - Not accurate

Listing Office: Coldwell Banker St.Croix Realty - GB

Office Phone: 340-778-7000

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.


Search powered by FBS Products
FIND YOUR DREAM PROPERTY
Property Type
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Property Sub Types
Select one or more locations to search for properties
to
to
Active
Pending
More Search Options

Contact Us

Would you like to learn more about a property you see or are you considering listing your property? We can help!

About David Fedeles

Twice voted Best Real Estate Broker on St. Croix. Coldwell Banker President's Circle three years in a row. Read More…
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

St. Croix and New York

David Fedeles is a licensed real estate broker in both St. Croix USVI and New York. If you are looking for your dream home in America’s Paradise, David is ready to work with you!

Contact David Fedeles today!

Tel: 340-778-7000
Cell: 917-494-2729
davidfedelesstx@gmail.com
Office Location:
Coldwell Banker St. Croix Realty | Gallows Bay Mkt
5030 Anchor Way, Suite 12 | Christiansted, VI 00820

Copyright © 2026 · AgentPress Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in